Hillside Geometry (& new Minerva Photo)

Photos © Mark Hertzberg

My cameras and I have been to Taliesin many times. My challenge at any Wright site is to photograph it with a fresh eye each visit. I was able to interpret the geometry of Wright’s “forest” in the drafting room at Hillside from a new perspective recently. I welcome your comments, unless they reopen the debate about the Foundation and the School. The treat at the end of this blog entry is my latest portrait of our dear friend Minerva, also taken Friday May 20.

LR Hillside Drafting Room 5.20.22 003.jpg

LR Hillside Drafting Room 5.20.22 012.jpg

LR Hillside Drafting Room 5.20.22 017.jpg

As we look at the drafting tables below, the unknowns, of course, are what renderings and plans were drawn at which table, and by whom. Among countless others, one of the architects (and students) who counted this as their office was Charles Montooth, Minerva’s late husband.

LR Hillside Drafting Room 5.20.22 015.jpg

LR Hillside Drafting Room 5.20.22 044.jpg

LR Hillside Drafting Room 5.20.22 018.jpg

LR Hillside Drafting Room 5.20.22 033.jpg

LR Hillside Drafting Room 5.20.22 046.jpg

LR Hillside Drafting Room 5.20.22 056.jpg

LR Hillside Drafting Room 5.20.22 048.jpg

LR Hillside Drafting Room 5.20.22 055.jpg

LR Hillside Drafting Room 5.20.22 060.jpg

Minerva Montooth 5.20.22a.jpg

Links:

https://www.taliesinpreservation.org

https://wrightinracine.wordpress.com/2021/09/29/the-marvelous-minerva-montooth/

Keep scrolling down to see earlier blog entries…

Photographing my Friend Minerva Montooth

(c) Mark Hertzberg (2019)

Olgivanna Wright could not have picked a better and more congenial assistant for 25 years than Minerva Montooth, who I am privileged to call a friend. Make that “Friend” with a Capital F. We have been privileged to know Minerva Montooth since May 2003 when her late husband Charles invited me to give my “Wright in Racine” presentation in the theater at Hillside Home and School (that was indeed a heady invitation for a burgeoning journalist-student of Wright’s work!). Minerva has kindly invited us to the annual celebration of Frank Lloyd Wright’s birthday at Taliesin every year since then.

I visit Minerva in her apartment at Taliesin whenever I am on campus helping lead Road Scholar explorations of Wright’s work in Wisconsin https://www.roadscholar.org/find-an-adventure/22976/architectural-masterworks-of-frank-lloyd-wright

Last week Minerva told me how she came to join the Wright community at Taliesin West in 1952 (gosh, I was only 18 months old!). She has a keen photographic eye. I admired the magnificent lighting of a photo of Charles, who died in December 2014, in her living room, not knowing that she was the photographer. When it was time for me to leave, I couldn’t just leave; after all my camera first had to photograph Minerva and Fifi:

Minerva Montooth Fifi 9.25.19 003.jpg

Minerva Montooth Fifi 9.25.19 009.jpg

Below are some of my earlier photos of Charles and Minerva:Evening at Taliesin 2004 008.jpg

Charles on the “Birdwalk” at Taliesin, Wright birthday celebration, 2004.

P50 JT Charles Montooth LR .jpg

Charles at The Prairie School in Wind Point (Racine), October 2003, with plans for the addition to the athletic center. Charles designed the original school building and each subsequent addition. He worked with Floyd Hamblen on the addition.

Johnson Athletic Center011 LR.jpg

Minerva and Charles at the dedication of the new facility, January 2005.

Johnson Athletic Center014 LR.jpg

Charles accepts accolades at the dedication.

By the way, if you email Minerva or write her something on Facebook, don’t expect a reply during your normal business hours: she is a confirmed computer night owl…1 a.m. is not an unusual time stamp for her.

Minerva Montooth 6.11.16 001.JPG

Minerva at the 2016 Wright birthday celebration.

We love you, Minerva!

 

Poking Around Taliesin With My Cameras

(c) Mark Hertzberg (2019)

Taliesin 6.8.19 003.jpg

This is the third installment this spring in my photographic discoveries at Taliesin…based on the premise that one can indeed see new things even on one’s umpteenth visit to a building designed by Frank Lloyd Wright. This visit was the weekend of June 8…when we were privileged to stay overnight in the Rose guest room after Minerva Montooth’s and Taliesin Preservation’s annual celebration of Wright’s birthday.

Taliesin 6.8.19 008.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 010.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 011.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 013.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 017.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 024.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 025.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 029.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 030.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 031.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 032.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 033.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 034.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 036.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 037.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 038.jpg

Taliesin 6.8.19 040.jpg

Yes, as seen above, sometimes there is a reason I bring a camera into the bathroom!

Taliesin 6.8.19 045.jpg

There are, indeed, gnats and mosquitoes on a warm spring evening.

Taliesin 6.8.19 047.jpg

 

Happy 152nd Birthday, Frank Lloyd Wright

(c) Mark Hertzberg (2019)

It is always a joy to mark Frank Lloyd Wright’s birthday at Taliesin at a party hosted by the always-gracious Minerva Montooth and Taliesin Preservation. The celebration, which is always on a Saturday, was on June 8, his birth date.This year we had the privilege of staying overnight at Taliesin for the first time because I was giving a presentation the next day at Hillside about my new book about Penwern, the Fred B. Jones estate on Delavan Lake.

2019 Wright Birthday 006.jpg

Caroline Hamblen, left, Director of Programs, and Kyle Adams, Events Manager, show Minerva the traditional Frank Lloyd Wright birthday cake, made from his favorite cake recipe.

 

Dixie Legler Guerrero chats with Minerva.

2019 Wright Birthday 024.jpg

2019 Wright Birthday 001.jpg

2019 Wright Birthday 011.jpgCarrie Rodamaker, Executive Director of Taliesin Preservation, speaks under a lovely evening sky. This year’s guests were not subjected to the heat and humidity that has beset past birthday celebrations.2019 Wright Birthday 023.jpg

2019 Wright Birthday 015.jpgAaron Betsky, Dean of the School of Architecture at Taliesin

2019 Wright Birthday 017.jpgBenjamin Feiner played for the guests.

2019 Wright Birthday 020.jpg

2019 Wright Birthday 022.jpg

2019 Wright Birthday 025.jpg

2019 Wright Birthday 030.jpg

2019 Wright Birthday 031.jpgMinerva holds Fifi as the celebration winds down at 9:30 p.m.

 

Celebrating Wright at Taliesin and Stillbend

(c) Mark Hertzberg 2017

There are Wright celebrations aplenty this year to commemorate the 150th anniversary of Frank Lloyd Wright’s birth on June 8, 1867 in Richland Center, Wisconsin.

The annual Wright birthday cocktail reception and dinner celebration at Taliesin, organized by Minerva Montooth and co-sponsored by Taliesin Preservation (the reception at Taliesin) and the Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation (dinner at Hillside), was Saturday evening. The photos of the Taliesin celebration are followed by photos of a celebration the next day at Stillbend, Wright’s Bernard Schwartz House (1939) in Two Rivers, Wisconsin. The guests at Stillbend included Steve Schwartz who shared his memories of growing up in the house. Michael Ditmer, steward of Stillbend, wondered if Wright have approved of the fuss. Read through to the end for my thoughts and then post your thoughts in the Comments link.

Wright 150th Taliesin 047.jpg

Minerva was ebullient – as always – as she greeted her guests:

Wright 150th Taliesin 013.jpg

Sara Lomasz Flesch, left, Aron Meudt-Thering, and Erik Flesch of Taliesin Preservation help guests with refreshments on a hot and humid evening during the reception:

Wright 150th Taliesin 014.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 003.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 022.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 024.jpg

The guests included Steve and Lynette Erickson Sikora, stewards of the Malcolm Willey House in Minneapolis:

Wright 150th Taliesin 025.jpg

Stuart Graff, President and CEO of the Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation, joined by his husband, Rob Chambers, sported a concrete (really) bow tie:

Wright 150th Taliesin 017.jpg

Souvenir photos were in order for many guests:

Wright 150th Taliesin 001.jpg

Musicians Effi Casey, Caroline Hamblen, Shannon McFarley, Ethan Ewer, Steven Ewer, Laurie Riss, and Eliana Baccas played a concerto before remarks by Tim Wright (one of Wright’s grandchildren), Graff, Aaron Betsky (Dean of the Frank Lloyd Wright School of Architecture), and Carrie Rodamaker (Executive Director & Director of Operations at Taliesin Preservation):

Wright 150th Taliesin 027.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 032.jpg

Tim Wright (whose father was Robert Llewellyn Wright), reminisced about his grandfather who he met for the first time when he was 13, at Taliesin. He drew chuckles when he said the architect greeted him asking quite directly, “How do you like shoveling shit and pulling tits?” Timothy confessed to the guests that he had neither shoveled manure nor milked a cow yet, even though he had been at Taliesin for several weeks.

Wright 150th Taliesin 035.jpg

The birthday feast seems to appear magically every year. Two of the magicians Saturday were Jay Anderson, an apprentice chef at Taliesin, and Chef Barbara Wright (no relation to the architect). They were photographed preparing the lemon butter asparagus and rosemary new potatoes which accompanied the spinach and feta cheese stuffed chicken:

Wright 150th Taliesin 042.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 045.jpg

Guests, below, found the menu as they unfolded origami found in little boxes at the tables:

Wright 150th Taliesin 049.jpg

The healthy menu was followed by the presumably less healthy (but no less tasty) traditionally named Frank Lloyd Wright’s Birthday Cake and a toast to Wright by Graff:

Wright 150th Taliesin 051.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 053.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 054.jpg

The origami menu presentation and decorative lights were made by students Lorraine Etchell and Xinxuan Liu:

Wright 150th Taliesin 055.jpg

WRIGHT CELEBRATION AT STILLBEND:

Michael Ditmer, steward of Stillbend, Wright’s Bernard Schwartz House in Two Rivers, Wisconsin, hosted his own celebration at the house Sunday afternoon.

Wright 150th Taliesin 058.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 012.jpgWright 150th Taliesin 008.jpg

Steve Schwartz, whose parents commissioned the house in 1940, delighted guests with his recollections of growing up in the house from the time he was three years old. He said that Wright named the estate for the bend in the river at the site he picked out for the house which evolved from the 1938 Wright design for LIFE Magazine’s feature of  “Eight Houses for Modern Living” ostensibly for a family from Minneapolis.

Wright 150th Taliesin 040.jpgWright 150th Taliesin 020.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 028.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 032.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 037.jpg

Schwartz had a treehouse in the maple behind him in the first photo below:Wright 150th Taliesin 029.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 030.jpg

He said he hoped someone would ask him what it was like to come back to the house, and had prepared a poem entitled Home Again:

The river curves, a still bend

Flocks off honking geese flying in formation

To seek gentler climes.

Firelight illumines sooty

History of joyous life.

All is in harmony

Quietly outwitting temporal arguments

Of color and placement.

Patterns, the rising heat swirls outward

Taking conversations of generations.

Oh, to resist one’s youth

To capture, nourish and restore,

Remember the thread

That wove the future.

While guests at Taliesin were treated to classical music, Ditmer chose as entertainment a wonderful new as-yet-unamed jazz trio from Two Rivers which he decided should be named the Stillbend Jazz Trio, including vocalist Vida Martin.

Wright 150th Taliesin 061.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 074.jpgWright 150th Taliesin 071.jpgWright 150th Taliesin 080.jpg

Wright 150th Taliesin 071.jpgWright 150th Taliesin 068.jpgWright 150th Taliesin 069.jpgWright 150th Taliesin 070.jpgDitmer asked me at the end of the day what Wright would have thought of this commemoration of his birthday. Consider that Stillbend was a gathering place for both friends and strangers that afternoon. Consider that the little boy who grew up there was back to experience the house again. Consider that the guests were treated to live music, Consider that the acoustics in the living room were perfect. Indeed, the house was being enjoyed just as Wright intended. He likely would have been pleased.

Wright Birthday Bash at Taliesin

(c) Mark Hertzberg

Taliesin Pano.jpg

A crisp blue sky greeted guests at the annual Taliesin celebration of Frank Lloyd Wright’s birthday Saturday June 11. Wright was born June 8, 1867.

Minerva Montooth, who was an assistant to Olgivanna Wright, and whose late husband, Charles, was also a member of the Taliesin Fellowship, greeted guests, as is her custom at the celebration. Minerva lives at Taliesin. Mary Jane Hamilton, a Wright scholar from Madison, is behind her in the photo.

Minerva Montooth 6.11.16 004.jpg

Fewer guests than usual gathered outside because it was so warm and humid, even at 6:30 p.m.

2016 Wright Birthday Taliesin 002.jpg

Lovely evening light set the scene as guests made their way to Hillside School where Jason Silverman, residence life manager of the Frank Lloyd Wright School of Architecture directed them to the theater for the evening program.

2016 Wright Birthday Taliesin 007.jpg

2016 Wright Birthday Taliesin 008.jpg

DSC_8924.jpg

2016 Wright Birthday Taliesin 009.jpg

Stuart Graff, center, CEO of the Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation, introduced Aaron Betsky, Dean of the School of Architecture, and Eric O’Malley, right, of OAD (the Organic Architecture and Design archives) and the PrairieMod website.

2016 Wright Birthday Taliesin 014.jpg

O’Malley told the guests how moved he was seeing the original model of Wright’s San Francisco Call newspaper building when he visited Taliesin young. The model has been moved to the Museum of Modern Art, so OAD commissioned Stafford Norris to build this replica to be displayed at Hillside where the original model stood for years. Architect Randolph C. Henning was also present. Henning, O’Malley, and William Blair Scott are the three partners in OAD.

Call Building Model 001.jpg

The musical selection was Bach’s Brandenburg Concerto No. 3:

2016 Wright Birthday Taliesin 019.jpg

Dinner featured braised beef short rib with greens grown at Taliesin, topped off by the traditional homemade birthday cake.

2016 Wright Birthday Taliesin 021.jpg

2016 Wright Birthday Taliesin 022.jpg

2016 Wright Birthday Taliesin 023.jpg

2016 Wright Birthday Taliesin 027.jpg

Next year’s commemoration of the 150th anniversary of Wright’s birth will be marked by many special events, including a just-announced major exhibition at the Museum of Modern Art.

Wright and Like

(c) Mark Hertzberg

More than 400 people from across the country came to Racine a week ago for Frank Lloyd Wright Wisconsin’s annual Wright and Like tour. Ten sites were featured. Their architects included Wright, Edgar Tafel, Charles Montooth, John Randal McDonald, Hans Geyer, and Helmut Ajango.

Generally people who think of architecture in Racine tend to focus on Wright, Montooth, Tafel, and McDonald. But there is much more to Racine’s rich architectural heritage. Friday evening’s special presentation at Wingspread was the premiere presentation of an audio visual review of some twenty significant architects whose work is in Racine. Future presentations of the program will add Holabird and Root, Howard van Doren Shaw, and McKim, Mead, and White to the mix. These two photos show the line of people waiting to see Wright’s Thomas P. Hardy House before the tour opened.

Next year’s Wright and Like will be Saturday June 3 in Milwaukee.

Hardy 2.jpg

Hardy 1.jpg